Critique partners. Can't live with them, can't write a decent book without them.
Last night, after having a brain melting episode of revisions, I decided to take a break and look through a book I've been working on sporadically. Unfortunately, stapled to the top of the pages were the critique notes I got when I last sent them out.
Now, I have several critique partners and they all have a different set of skills, which creates a really well rounded set of revisions. One is really great at prose, another at character motivation, another at how well scenes work. Most of the time I come back feeling okay about their critiques. There are things to work on, but for the most part I feel like I've become a good self-editor.
But then. Then is my critique partner from hell. I get as anxious when I send something new to her, as I did when I sent out a brand new query letter. I chew my nails, I make baked goods. Hell, I even exercise for a distraction. That's right people. Exercise. She has the ability to point out plot holes that others have missed, sloppy writing, lazy characterization, and all in a few gut wrenching paragraphs.
I walk away from those emails with seething hatred.
This often spurs the following conversation
Husband: "If you don't like her notes, why do you keep sending her stuff?"
Me "It's because I don't like it that I like it."
Husband: "What?"
Me: "Exactly."
If you get a critique back and you hate that person, find them stupid, write epic poetry about how gross they are - chances are you've got yourself a pretty solid partner. Remember, you didn't ask this person to tell you how good you are, how great that scene worked (though it's nice when that happens) you asked them to help you make your book better. Not make your ego bigger.
Which is why when I feel like my critique partners eyes are bleeding with my prose, I send pages to twitter strangers. Why? Because a stranger doesn't care about your feelings (although your regular CPs shouldn't care so much either). So often, while their critiques can seem the most harsh, they're also the most truthful. And you know who really doesn't care about your feelings? Agents. Editors. Readers.
So if you're out there, like I am, feeling a little teeth-gnashy over you latest notes, know that you're not alone. And be strong. After reading a grueling set of margin edits, take some time off. Think about what that person said, and why they said it. It's not there to hurt your feelings, or to make you feel bad about yourself, it's there because that person wants to help you make the book better. And remember, that's why you asked them to read it in the first place.